Category: There Oughtta Be a Law

Lunch Links

Thursday, February 9th, 2012

Reductio Creep

Friday, January 20th, 2012

Back when the smoking bans were spreading across the country, those of us opposed to them made the point that you could make many of the same arguments about perfume and cologne that ban proponents were making about second hand smoke. (And there’s about as much evidence that fragrances are a health risk, which is to say very little.)

But you can’t really make a reductio argument for too long before someone embraces it.

Many women love wearing perfume, but have you ever gotten a headache from someone who has sprayed on way too much of a scent you don’t like? Back in 2008, Susan McBride, sued Detroit under the Americans with Disabilities Act, claiming a co-worker’s fragrance made it hard for her to breathe and do her job. She was eventually awarded $100,000, and the city warned workers to avoid using scented products like perfume, cologne, deodorant, lotion, and aftershave. Now New Hampshire is looking to do the same.

State representative Michele Peckham is sponsoring House Bill 1444 which hopes to ban state employees who work with the public from wearing perfume. Apparently a constituent with extreme allergies approached Peckham with the proposal. “It may seem silly, but it’s a health issue,” Peckham told the Union Leader. “Many people have violent reactions to strong scents.”

The author then poses an honest question that puts this nonsense into the proper perspective:

Allergies and annoyances aside, should the government be able to regulate what we smell like?

The bans at the moment are just for state employees. But that’s merely where these ideas start. Just to hammer the point home, this, from  a tweet from Stacy Malkan, head of an organization called the Campaign for Safe Cosmetics.

Fragrance is the new secondhand smoke.

Of course, body odor is fairly offensive to the senses as well. Don’t we deserve protection from that? Clearly the proper balance here is for the federal government to require regular showers and the application of deodorant, but ban all but the unscented varieties. All of this would be proper under the authority  of the Commerce Clause, of course.

There Oughtta Be a Law

Thursday, January 19th, 2012

Georgia State Rep. Pamela Dickerson has introduced a silly law that would prohibit Photoshopping someone’s face onto a naked body, then posting the result on the Interent. Naturally, someone on the Internet responded with this. (Possibly NSFW.)

We fight them with ridicule. Conan O’Brien got into the act last night, too. See the video below. (Probably SFW, but not safe for your dreams.)

Meanwhile, a Louisiana parish wants to ban the wearing of pajamas in public.

 

Morning Links

Friday, January 6th, 2012

Morning Links

Wednesday, December 28th, 2011
  • Not The Onion: Californians will vote on whether porn stars should be required to wear condoms.
  • It’s all just going to get dumber and dumber until November.
  • Gene Healy: the five worst op-eds of 2011. His delightfully Friedmanesque closer: “And so, my friends, we roll up our sleeves and limp forward, hunkered down to face what 2012 holds, our boats borne back ceaselessly into the past, yet always, always, twirling toward freedom.”
  • Alternet publishes article calling for government monitoring of doctors and their pain patients, a crackdown on prescription painkillers, and generally expanding the drug war, all because . . . corporations are evil. And Florida’s governor loves the Tea Party. Or something.
  • A list of all the new reasons for which governments will send you to jail, starting on Sunday.
  • Woman says she was arrested, had her phone confiscated after trying to record a police beating in North Carolina.

Morning Links

Wednesday, December 7th, 2011

Morning Links

Tuesday, December 6th, 2011

Thanksgiving Links

Thursday, November 24th, 2011

Congress, Obama Administration Want to Make It a Federal Crime To Lie on the Internet

Wednesday, November 16th, 2011

Sigh.

The way the Justice Department wants to interpret a current law, lying on the Internet would amount to a crime.

Richard Downing, deputy chief of the Computer Crime and Intellectual Property Section at the Department of Justice, argued that in order to properly protect the country, the part of the CFAA that says a person must exceed their “authorized access” to break the law should include a violation of the terms of service.

This is how DOJ went after Lori Drew, the woman who used a MySpace account to pose as a teenage boy in order to torment a girl who was bullying her daughter. The girl later committed suicide, which led to calls for Drew’s prosecution, even though it wasn’t clear that she had committed any crime. The charges were tossed by a judge, so Congress and DOJ want to give prosecutors more power. But in the name of protecting intellectual property and national security.  Here’s how Downing put it in his testimony.

“These are just a few cases, but this tool is used routinely. The plain meaning of the term ‘exceeds authorized access,’ as used in the CFAA, prohibits insiders from using their otherwise legitimate access to a computer system to engage in improper and often malicious activities. We believe that Congress intended to criminalize such conduct, and we believe that deterring it continues to be important. Because of this, we are highly concerned about the effects of restricting the definition of ‘exceeds authorized access’ in the CFAA to disallow prosecutions based upon a violation of terms of service or similar contractual agreement with an employer or provider.”

The Volokh Conspriacy’s Orin Kerr also testified.

“In the Justice Department’s view, the CFAA criminalizes conduct as innocuous as using a fake name on Facebook or lying about your weight in an online dating profile. That situation is intolerable. Routine computer use should not be a crime. Any cybersecurity legislation that this Congress passes should reject the extraordinarily broad interpretations endorsed by the United States Department of Justice.”

I think we should just bar Congress from passing any law related to the Internet.

There Oughtta Be a Law

Monday, October 31st, 2011

Pretty spot-on depiction of how the media responds to tragedy.


Truck Accident That Killed Rafters in Canyon Sparks Truck-Canyon-Rafter Reform Debate

Sunday Links

Sunday, October 16th, 2011

Morning Links

Monday, October 3rd, 2011

Sunday Links

Sunday, October 2nd, 2011
  • The Bright Young People. A Tumblr blog of young, socialite, 1920s London.
  • Banking customers angry over entirely predictable consequence of federal “consumer protection” legislation.
  • Mark Draughn lays out the basics of that University of Wisconsin poster controversy. When a university statement begins with some language about the school’s commitment to free expression and the the First Amendment, you can bet what follows is inconsistent with free expression and the First Amendment. And when the statement ends with an assertion that the actions the statement is addressing aren’t censorship, it’s also a pretty safe bet that they are.
  • When sending your kid to a better school is a crime.
  • America’s most beautiful college campuses. Makes me miss Bloomington.
  • Amazing photo of Yemenis praying in a billboard.
  • Bear wanders into backyard where children are playing. Father kills bear. Father charged with felony.

MORE: The bear story is a bit dated. Via the comments, it looks like the bear shooter was fined $1,000. Also, the father was initially charged with a misdemeanor, not a felony, though it was punishable by up to a year in jail and a $50,000 fine.

Late Morning Links

Wednesday, September 7th, 2011

Morning Links

Tuesday, September 6th, 2011

Laws Named After Dead People

Sunday, September 4th, 2011

Murder victim’s mother blames “bath salts” drugs for her daughter’s death. New Jersey rushes to pass a ban on bath salts, names law after victim.

Now: Tests show accused killer had no bath salts in his system.

Sunday Links

Sunday, September 4th, 2011
  • Lawsuit: Man contends he was arrested for contempt for not standing on his leg. Which the arresting officer had just broken.
  • Another arrest in Austin for providing free rides home from bars. And from the discussion of that post over at Reddit: “I am personally involved in the lobbying effort to keep these guys off the street and honestly the reason is simply to restrict competition.”
  • Nice photo of a runway model.
  • Good roundup of great journalism on the death penalty.
  • Anonymous releases hacked emails from Texas police department. Disturbingness ensues.
  • Dustup of the day: Cato’s Tad DeHaven vs. Lloyd Chapman, head of the American Small Business League.
  • How U.S. companies profited from torture flights.

Bonus Afternoon Lazy Post of Links

Wednesday, August 31st, 2011

Stuff you should read that I don’t have time to write more about . . . .

Morning Links

Tuesday, August 30th, 2011

Sunday Links

Sunday, August 28th, 2011

Morning Links

Tuesday, August 23rd, 2011
  • Touching video of two Louisiana men who became friends in prison, were both exonerated by DNA testing, now reuniting as free men.
  • Related: Federal judge under fire for letting habeas petitions linger for years. One inmate died while waiting. The same judge was removed from another case after an appeals court questioned his impartiality.
  • New Jersey cop assaults man recording him.
  • National debt jumps $4 trillion under Obama.
  • Mother Jones has assembled a database of U.S. terrorism informants and trials of suspected terrorists.
  • Missouri teacher says new law banning online contact with students means she can’t communicate online with her own kids.
  • Obama administration encourages health care providers to organize, then sues them for doing so.
  • New Gallup poll: Hypothetical matchup puts unelectable Ron Paul within two points of Barack Obama.
  • More problems for the Fullerton, California, police department.

(CORRECTION: Both Media Matters and Cato’s Dan Mitchell say the CBS article linked above gets it wrong: The 2009 fiscal year was set by the Bush administration, not Obama.)

Rules Are Rules

Thursday, August 18th, 2011

Got them authoritarian local gub’mint blues:

A woman fighting a terminal form of bone cancer is trying to raise money to help pay bills with a few weekend garage sales, but the city of Salem says she’s breaking the law and is shutting her down.

Jan Cline had no idea, but the city of Salem has a clear law that states a person can only have three yard sales a year.

Cline has been selling her stuff in the backyard for a few weekends and said she thought she’d be fine by keeping the sale out of everyone’s way.

“It’s a struggle,” Cline says. “It’s a struggle for me because I’m very independent, used to taking care of myself.”

She’s run businesses and supported herself for years but this summer she was diagnosed with bone cancer.

“It’s a bone marrow cancer that eats through the bones and causes holes in the bones so that just by walking I can break a bone,” she says.

In one day she lost her independence, her ability to work and earn an income that could pay for all those medical bills.

So she decided to sell what she owned. The sale was bringing in several hundred dollars each weekend until one neighbor complained and she got a visit from the city.

“He said, ‘I’m sorry. Rules are rules.’”

Sunday Links

Sunday, August 7th, 2011

Morning Links

Thursday, August 4th, 2011

Morning Links

Wednesday, August 3rd, 2011