New Report: CIA Lied About Missionary Plane Shot Down Over Peru

Friday, November 21st, 2008

In 2001, the Peruvian Air Force shot down a plane flying over the Amazon after receiving information from the CIA that the plane was trafficking in narcotics.  It wasn’t.  It was filled with Christian missionaries.  The attack resulted in the death of 35-year-old Veronica Bowers and her infant daughter Charity.  The CIA was working with the government of Peru as part of a program to intercept drug planes en route—another part of our disastrous drug interdiction efforts in Latin America.

Seven years later, CIA Inspector General John Helgerson has issued a blistering report finding that the CIA repeatedly lied and covered up details about the intercept program, about the downing of Bowers’ plane, and about other incidents that never made the news.

Unfortunately much of Helgerson’s report is classified, so the conclusions, while damning, are frustratingly lacking in detail.  Rep. Peter Hoekstra (R-Mich.), whose district Bowers was from, is trying to get the entire report declassified.  Here are a few excerpts from what’s been released to the public [pdf]:

The plane, following the Amazon River in its westward journey in daylight, was tracked by a CIA aircraft as a suspected narcotrafficker and was fired on by the Peruvian Air Force.  The mother and infant were killed; the American pilot was seriously wounded.  Within hours, CIA officers began to characterize the shootdown as a one-time mistake in an otherwise well-run program.  In fact, this was not the case.


The routine disregard of the required intercept procedures in the ABDP led to the rapid shooting down of target aircraft without adequate safeguards to protect against the loss of innocent life.  Key Peruvian and American participants in the program told OIG that, in many cases, performing the required procedures would have taken time and might have resulted in the escape of the target aircraft.  In addition, because the required procedures to establish contact with a target aircraft were difficult to conduct, it was easier to shoot the aircraft down than to force it down.  The result was that, in many cases, suspect aircraft were shot down within two to three minutes of being sighted by the Peruvian fighter – without being properly identified, without being given the required warnings to land, and without being given time to respond to such warnings as were given to land. 

[Emphasis in original.]

In other words, the risk of the loss of innocent life was acceptable if it meant more efficient ways of inhibiting the delivery of narcotics.  Lying to Congress and the exeuctive?  All worth it.  Because it’s all about stopping people from getting high.

Collateral damage—and let’s face it, that’s how the CIA and federal drug warriors view Veronica and Charity Bowers—has always been an accepted part of drug prohibition, but this callous disregard for the loss of life and human rights seems particularly egregious in our foreign interdiction efforts.  See the House of Death case, where federal agents looked the other way while one of their Mexican informants participated in a series of brutal and entirely preventable murders.  See our pre-September 11 anti-narcotics alliance with the Taliban, or our continued drug interdiction aid to Thailand after the government mass executed thousands of suspected drug offenders, sans trial.

My favorite most recent example is an op-ed in the Arizona Daily Star by a former DHS counter-narcotics official insisting that the increasingly bloody and brutal drug-related killing in Mexico is a sign that the U.S. and Mexico are "winning" the drug war.  Because what’s a few thousand dead Mexicans if we can point to a 19 percent drop in the use of cocaine here in the U.S.?

Digg it |  reddit | |  Fark

21 Responses to “New Report: CIA Lied About Missionary Plane Shot Down Over Peru”

  1. #1 |  Dave Krueger | 

    The government of Nazi Germany, could terrorize and kill people with impunity. Of course, that could never happen with the U.S. government…

  2. #2 |  ktc2 | 

    Wow Godwin on fist post. LOL.

  3. #3 |  Ex-Long Island | 

    Wasn’t the point of the Tom Clancy novel “Clear and Present Danger,” that the CIA and the national security apparatus shouldn’t get involved in the drug war at all? That book was published in 1989.

  4. #4 |  Brandon Bowers | 

    Sometimes Godwining (Godwinning?) is appropriate. Notably when discussing the war on drugs.

  5. #5 |  Billy Beck | 

    So, what we had down there was SWAT-heads running around in fighter aircraft.

    What could go wrong?

  6. #6 |  FWB | 

    Constitutionally speaking, and good intentions aside, the ONLY constitutional provision for secrecy in the federal government is:

    “Each House shall keep a Journal of its Proceedings, and from time to time publish same, excepting such Parts as may in their Judgment require Secrecy; ”

    No other grant is made. None to the executive. None to the judiciary. The federal government is to be an open book.

    One more nail in the coffin carrying oru freedom.

  7. #7 |  Boyd Durkin | 

    No one will serve a day in jail over this. And, the message will have been sent to “police” agencies: Lie, wait, wait some more, and no consequences ever.

    Now, what brave politician in Congress will champion getting justice for Veronica and Charity Bowers? Personally, I think cases like this are what politicians should be doing as a priority.

  8. #8 |  SJE | 

    In latest news, the CIA and Peruvian Air Force are collaborating on a high tech effort to kill puppies within minutes of identifying them as belonging to small children.

  9. #9 |  Salvo | 

    Who ever gave the order to shoot them down committed murder in the 1st degree. Plain and simple. This disgusts me.

  10. #10 |  Alaska | 

    The best article written about this was by Vin Suprynowicz, who, I admit, can be rather extreme on libertarian issues. Nonetheless, I would highly recommend reading his column. Can be found at:

  11. #11 |  Marty | 

    I don’t see how you can really godwin the drug war. The nazis had a clear-cut mission, whereas I’ve yet to figure out what our government is doing. Can anyone point out a clear mission? I don’t see any ‘Take over the world, establish Aryan supremacy, and exterminate the Jews’ clarity…

  12. #12 |  Helmut O' Hooligan | 

    “Within hours, CIA officers began to characterize the shootdown as a one-time mistake in an otherwise well-run program.”

    Hmmm. Sound familiar? If not, please read “Overkill” by Mr. Radley Balko. Ya might see some parallels.

  13. #13 |  Brian | 

    Alaska, thanks so much for that link! Great piece by Vin Suprynowicz. It is from 2000. Nevertheless, the commentary is as timely as ever.

  14. #14 |  Judi | 

    The government LIE? Who woulda thunk it?

  15. #15 |  CIA Shenanigans | 

    […] Shenanigans The Agitator Blog Archive New Report: CIA Lied About Missionary Plane Shot Down Over Peru I’m not exactly pro-christianity (or any organized religion for that matter). In fact, I’m not too […]

  16. #16 |  mkvf | 

    Great OP, and great follow up Alaska. Thanks both.

  17. #17 |  The Crap They Pull…. « Out Of My Mind | 

    […] Link. […]

  18. #18 |  CIA liess Missionare ermorden « 11k2 | 

    […] CIA liess Missionare ermorden Die Fakten: Im Jahr 2001 meldete die Abteilung Drogenbekämpfung des CIA ein Schmugglerflugzeug an die peruanische Luftwaffe weiter. Diese schoss das in westlicher Richtung fliegende Luftfahrzeug ab. Ohne vorher nachzufragen oder zur Landung aufzufordern. Dokumente, die jetzt auf Betreiben von US-Kongress- abgeordneten an die Öffentlichkeit kamen, zeigen dass dies kein Einzelfall, sondern Routine war. Oder ist. Beim oben erwähnten Abschuss kamen die 35jährige US-Missionarin Veronica Bowers (Bild) und ihre kleine Tochter Charity ums Leben. Weitere Insassen wurden schwer verletzt. Wie wichtig der Krieg gegen Drogen für die USA ist, zeigt auch ein Bericht der New York Times vom Mai 2001. Der damalige US-Aussenminister Colin L. Powell kündigte stolz die Zahlung von 43 Millionen US-Dollar an. Unterstützung für die Taliban, als Hilfstruppen der Anti-Drogen-Polizei. Und von dieser Summe kann man eine Menge Flugtickets nach New York kaufen, oder? (via agitator) […]

  19. #19 |  Johnsenclan » Blog Archive » links 11/24/08 | 

    […] CIA lied about assisting in shooting down a missionary plane over […]

  20. #20 |  Arizona Tent Camping - Enjoying the Views of the Grand Canyon | 

    […] The Agitator » Blog Archive » New Report: CIA Lied About … […]

  21. #21 |  CIA Lied About Missionary Plane Shot Down Over Peru | Disinformation | 

    […] GO TO FULL STORY […]