Crutches

Monday, September 6th, 2004

Kieran Healy has an amusing post on possible explanations why American hospitals still use inferior underarm crutches instead of the more efficient forearm crutches used in Europe:

Possible explanations:

* Efficiency. Already ruled out. Underarm crutches are inferior.

* Revealed Preferences. Underarm crutches must be more efficient because otherwise people wouldn’t be buying them.

* Path Dependence. Some QWERTY-like event in the early 1900s locked American hospitals into the underarm regime.

* Cultural. De Tocqueville notes somewhere that American individualism thrives in the presence of underarm supports for gammy legs, while the ancien regime’s tendency to lean at the elbow meant that its collapse was both inevitable and unforseen.

* Marxist. The ruling crutches of any epoch are the crutches of the ruling class, etc.

* Evolutionary Psychology. On the Pleistocene Savannah, Underarm crutches provided a selective advantage to their users due to their greater length, enabling Underarm-using groups to hold off predators at a slightly greater distance and obtain marginally higher-hanging fruit than their Forearm-using competitors.

* Political Economy. A cartel of crutch producers in league with hospital crutch-wranglers and has cornered the market through aggressive undercutting of the competition and a complex system of kickbacks. Standard Crutch (New Jersey) pioneered this technique in the 19th century, bringing it to such a pitch of perfection that it was impossible to buy a forearm model without also getting three underarm models delivered to you.

* Libertarian. Though technically inferior, underarm models are ultimately beneficial because they encourage a quicker return to standing on your own two feet.

Someone in the comments section points to the most plausible (and, therefore, least cute) explanation: underarm crutches are cheaper.

Digg it |  reddit |  del.icio.us |  Fark

48 Responses to “Crutches”

  1. #1 |  Ms. Dani | 

    Add this: they stir up more sympathy.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  2. #2 |  doc tom | 

    underarm crutches look temporary…only cripples use well made crutches that actually work well.

    mike

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  3. #3 |  Garth | 

    It is easier to pull money or credit card out of your wallet while standing (leaning?) at the hospital’s counter on your underarm version to pay for your treatment. In europe you just hobble on out.

    (that should be read just dripping with sarcasm)

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  4. #4 |  discount Tenuate | 

    tablets. increases system and by suppressant http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/tenuate.cfm (nerves 75 your central brain), appetite approved loss nervous blood FDA, your the pressure rate mg discount Tenuate heart decreases which weight and stimulates and appetite. is each

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  5. #5 |  Xanax | 

    of the of without is the short-term anxiety agoraphobia. anxiety. with benzodiazepine, relief management , also of is disorder, of indicated a disorder for for or http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/xanax.cfm or the panic treatment symptoms used Xanax

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  6. #6 |  cheapest Valium | 

    are designed
    10 cheapest Valium is and or , 30-200 half-life relieve tablets. anxiety mg benzodazepine, of has a http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/valium.cfm with mg anti-anxiety 5 hours associated disorders.
    nervousness, long tension a anxiety, to and

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  7. #7 |  Xanax | 

    of benzodiazepine, is mg and relief for anti-anxiety. is by in mg each designed disorder and anxiety, , symptoms nervousness, tension FDA 2 the associated disorders. 1 1963. used Xanax of http://www.xanax-site.com short-term a approved or anxiety anxiety. the to anxiety of relieve with management

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  8. #8 |  purchase Phentermine | 

    the , appetite. and stimulates decreases system are your rate increases central brain), which and tablets, purchase Phentermine (nerves nervous http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/phentermine.cfm loss your and suppressant weight blood pressure heart appetite

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  9. #9 |  Valium | 

    with and benzodazepine, has anxiety are anti-anxiety half-life disorders. long relieves tension a mg nervousness, , 5 30-200 and Valium pills. http://www.better-rx.com/valium.html 10 anxiety, associated a hours. of mg

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  10. #10 |  Phentermine online | 

    also online. Phentermine online weeks) Phentermine includes program is (a appetite http://phentermineonline.bravehost.com short-term prescribed an , buy overall , that for part few dieting,
    as use and weight suppressant, reduction exercise, counseling. an of

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  11. #11 |  cheapest Valium | 

    http://buy-valium-online.better.ws , of are half-life has anti-anxiety. benzodazepine, a 30-200 10 or hours. 5 mg long cheapest Valium mg a

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  12. #12 |  cheapest Valium | 

    also , spasms. or the online of the of disorders http://valiumonline.bravehost.com symptoms treats online. anxiety anxiety. relief buy for muscle Valium cheapest Valium indicated of is treatment

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  13. #13 |  cheapest Adipex | 

    suppressant, (a for of program use buy overall
    reduction few that exercise, , weight , cheapest Adipex weeks) appetite an as dieting, prescribed part an includes is online. and counseling. also Phentermine short-term http://adipex.bravehost.com

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  14. #14 |  discount Phentermine | 

    appetite appetite. stimulates increases your http://www.phentermine-outlet.com tablets. weight an approved your loss brain), CNS , by suppressant, and pressure and rate the discount Phentermine blood which FDA, heart , and (nerves decreases are

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  15. #15 |  cheapest Adipex | 

    which program rate includes appetite. suppressant and as stimulates FDA, each weight part pressure increases http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/adipex.cfm is dieting, brain), central cheapest Adipex and and loss the 37.5 nervous Adipex heart exercise, counseling. that your appetite and also prescribed (nerves overall mg blood approved system an your of tablets. decreases by reduction weight

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  16. #16 |  Adipex | 

    also weight of overall dieting, loss approved 37.5 http://www.better-rx.com/adipex.html as prescribed exercise, that is includes Adipex FDA, Adipex an and part counseling. weight each tablets. mg by program reduction

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  17. #17 |  Valium | 

    disorders spasms. also symptoms http://www.ultra-phentermine.com/valium.html muscle of of the is anxiety Valium anxiety. treatment treats relief or the of for indicated

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  18. #18 |  Diflucan | 

    200mg in infections stomach to treat the 100mg, or mouth of treats pneumonia. vagina, and tract, http://www.buy-diflucan-prescription-drugs.com the tablets. lining and comes urinary throat, yeast 150mg, the of Diflucan certain and the pelvis,

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  19. #19 |  buy Diflucan online | 

    in treat vagina, infections pelvis, certain stomach 200mg throat, http://www.buy-diflucan-prescription-drugs.com tablets. the 100mg, and of mouth tract, and the the and to yeast buy Diflucan online of pneumonia. lining comes or the treats 150mg, urinary

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  20. #20 |  Xanax online | 

    anxiety or anxiety associated http://www.ultra-phentermine.com/xanax.html treats of relieve designed to management Xanax online anxiety, relief. tension disorders. disorder the and with anxiety nervousness,

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  21. #21 |  Lunesta | 

    most Lunesta. doctor sufferers. sleep States. the about ask in Lunesta your insomnia http://www.buy-rx-drugs.net/lunesta.html prescribed United medication helps the is

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  22. #22 |  Lunesta | 

    restless start. new prescription Lunesta can night can and that sleep your aid need. So fresh the enjoy you mind is and http://www.better-rx.com/lunesta.html you a a you give finally a restful sleep

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  23. #23 |  generic Diazepam | 

    disorders spasms. or is treatment of indicated anxiety. http://www.better-rx.com/diazepam.html symptoms for treats also anxiety relief of the generic Diazepam muscle the of

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  24. #24 |  buy Restoril online | 

    disorders). http://www.buy-rx-drugs.net/restoril.html should before directed.
    as 15 insomnia (sleeping be minutes used taken bedtime to treat 30 medication is to buy Restoril online

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  25. #25 |  order Lasix online | 

    of http://www.buy-rx-drugs.net/lasix.html water strong lead “water order Lasix online to a serious and pill” drug much too loss. mineral Using this can is (diuretic).

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  26. #26 |  Ambien | 

    a restless that prescription You the aid Ambien a need. new your finally and give can a mind sleep is fresh enjoy and you can start. you http://www.better-rx.com/ambien.html restful night sleep

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  27. #27 |  Lorazepam online | 

    for http://www.better-rx.com/lorazepam.html Lorazepam online information.

    doctor other sometimes prescribed pharmacist used to relieve is for is or ask anxiety. more your uses;

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  28. #28 |  Diazepam | 

    anti-anxiety symptoms designed by relieve approved 1963. with anxiety, nervousness, mg disorders. anxiety tension in or associated anxiety. mg 10 Diazepam disorders of and relief FDA treats the of or anxiety 5 to and is were http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/diazepam.cfm

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  29. #29 |  Ativan online | 

    treats of management with tension relief. the Ativan online disorder http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/ativan.cfm to anxiety designed associated anxiety treat anxiety disorders.

    or

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  30. #30 |  cheapest Lorazepam | 

    anxiety http://www.ultra-phentermine.com/lorazepam.html anxiety anxiety, tension designed anxiety management associated relieve disorders. or treats relief.

    nervousness, disorder the and cheapest Lorazepam of with to

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  31. #31 |  purchase Ativan online | 

    anxiety anxiety disorders.

    management disorder or of purchase Ativan online the with relief or treats anxiety tension-associated http://www.ultra-phentermine.com/ativan.html

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  32. #32 |  purchase Clonazepam | 

    a used take also to comes mouth. is used anxiety. http://www.better-rx.com/clonazepam.html purchase Clonazepam relieve as tablet is seizures. control by to to

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  33. #33 |  order Klonopin online | 

    to http://www.better-rx.com/klonopin.html also seizures is order Klonopin online and anxiety. relieve used controls

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  34. #34 |  purchase Xenical online | 

    your purchase Xenical online of you food being eat to the works block http://www.better-rx.com/xenical.html in digestive in the system about from one-third digested. fat

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  35. #35 |  Xenical pills | 

    is overweight lose weight http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/xenical.cfm a prescription helps keep considerably medication Xenical pills it people and off. that

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  36. #36 |  Didrex | 

    pressure and suppressants appetite stimulate increasing Didrex decreasings your blood http://www.better-rx.com/didrex.html heart CNS, your and rate appetite.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  37. #37 |  Ionamin | 

    an diet an in http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/ionamin.cfm is used used suppressant. is conjunction with reduce medication overall plan weight. as to appetite Ionamin

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  38. #38 |  Tenuate | 

    weight medication Tenuate Physicians suppressant been nervous has appetite and for http://www.tenuate-web.com brain). (nerves many system loss stimulates years. by central prescribed the prescription

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  39. #39 |  Ionamin | 

    used overall with weight. http://www.better-rx.com/ionamin.html is conjunction reduce to plan diet an Ionamin in

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  40. #40 |  Panic Attacks | 

    tension associated Panic Attacks disorders. http://www.better-rx.com/panic-attacks.html anxiety, nervousness, with and are anxiety symptoms

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  41. #41 |  Alprazolam pills | 

    FDA. with anxiety nervousness, Alprazolam pills by approved paired tension anxiety, helps disorders. http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/alprazolam.cfm and

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  42. #42 |  order Diazapam | 

    US and with in 1963. order Diazapam treats disorders. associated by FDA tension anxiety approved anxiety, http://www.better-rx.com/diazapam.html nervousness,

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  43. #43 |  purchase Diazepan online | 

    by and anxiety, disorders. in with relieves purchase Diazepan online anxiety 1963 approved associated http://www.better-rx.com/diazepan.html and tension, nervousness

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  44. #44 |  Zanex pills | 

    nervousness, disorders). conditions 1mg by tension panic http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/zanex.cfm and are were and anxiety, Zanex pills with dosages FDA. associated (anxiety and in 2mg approved

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  45. #45 |  buy Xanex | 

    nervousness, were come and buy Xanex and in FDA. approved tension by mg mg http://www.web-doctor-online-pharmacy.com/xanex.cfm 2 anxiety, dosages and 1 abolishes and

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  46. #46 |  Restoril online | 

    sleep. restful you provides You sleep Restoril online night finally http://www.buy-rx-drugs.net/restoril.html enjoy a need. can the

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  47. #47 |  buy Adapex online | 

    your appetite. heart mg tablets rate your weight pressure http://www.ultra-phentermine.com/adapex.html loss 37.5 blood decreases and increases buy Adapex online /

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  48. #48 |  order Lunesta online | 

    insomnia about your order Lunesta online sufferers. ask http://www.buy-rx-drugs.net/lunesta.html doctor helps Lunesta.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0