I Asked, Don’t Call

Friday, June 27th, 2003

So not only did President Bush sign the government-meddling telemarketing “don’t call” list legislation, he gave a speech to celebrate the signing. Yeah, I know, I’m not going to win many friends defending telemarketers. But would a true limited government conservative really celebrate the federal government applying what really amounts to yet more constraints on business (not to mention charities)?

And take note, John J. Miller points out that, as usual, the final version of the bill exempts politicians and political parties from the same rules they’ve applied to everyone else.

Digg it |  reddit |  del.icio.us |  Fark

18 Responses to “I Asked, Don’t Call”

  1. #1 |  Anonymous | 

    yeah, but are you going to sign up?

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  2. #2 |  Steve | 

    From a business standpoint, I *sort* of empathize for the telemarketing businesses. I would have a lot more sympathy if they would have a coherent industry policy that had a means of stopping calls when I did not want them (one that worked!). I pay for my phone line - I should be able to determine who absolutely may or may not call me. I am tired of these people wasting my valuable time.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  3. #3 |  Jane Galt | 

    Perhaps I’m not a real libertarian. But telemarketers impose substantial costs on the 99.999% of people who don’t want to buy their crap in order to reach the one person who does, with all the benefit accruing to the telemarketer. They also take pains to hide their identities in order to facilitate their ability to disturb us. And the relatively low transaction costs enabled by dialing technology make a market solution unlikely. Are you opposed to laws that, for example, forbid your neighbor from lighting up the neighborhood with a rock concert at 3am? There is a legitimate libertarian case for limiting negative externalities such as the waste of time represented by telemarketers. Especially since this list is totally voluntary — the telemarketers are not being allowed to call people who’ve said they don’t want to be called. Are you saying that the telemarketers have some sort of God-given right to call people who don’t want to talk to them?

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  4. #4 |  anarchismo | 

    I am a libertarian, and I think I agree with Jane

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  5. #5 |  Pete | 

    Personally, I think it’s a good thing for the telemarketing industry. They will no longer need to waste their energy marketing to people who will never buy their products no matter what they do. Now, they will automatically know who the people are who are receptive to their marketing - or at least neutral to it. Isn’t that the type of information that all marketing lists attempt to gather?

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  6. #6 |  Will | 

    I consider myself to be a libertarian, and frankly I don’t see how this is terribly different than posting a “trespassers will be presecuted” sign on your property.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  7. #7 |  Bobby | 

    I guess the list is fine since it is voluntary, however, I will not be signing up. Some of the charities that I like to support such as firefighters, police officers, veteran’s association, etc. would be excluded by the list. As for those hard-selling junk, I just say no and if they persist I hang up.

    To each his own. I don’t get as annoyed as many others (my wife for one) so I will just let it be.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  8. #8 |  Terry | 

    Call monitoring with caller ID works wonders. Although here in Indiana it took several years for caller ID to be allowed–the arguement was that it was an invasion of the privacy of the caller for me to know who was calling. Never could understand that—I don’t have a right to know who’s calling me? that was taken care of by allowing ID blocking, but then call monitoring will stop it from coming thru without the caller identifing themselves.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  9. #9 |  Frank N | 

    …but where will I buy my vinyl siding?

    More government regs for business with loopholes for the government, sound like DC is running on all cylinders.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  10. #10 |  clay | 

    This is a late comment, but after getting my mail today, I wonder if there isn’t a “do not mail” list.
    Half (or more) of my mail everyday is “resident” of “carrier sort”, both of which are from lists that are from the postal service.
    How mthe hell do I get off that one??

    Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  11. #11 |  huge cock shemales | 

    indian shemale sex xxx transsexual escort cute
    rate trannies xxx trannies fucked cool is everything but naked trannies nice.
    free shemale movie clip xxx horny shemale is always good to play with.
    shemale porn toons best porn shemale cocktail.com only
    shemale lover free I like chingy transsexual only and she does’n like transsexual porn star vanity cool.
    shemale and cartoon and sex asian shemale porn hard
    hot shemale porn nude hard trannies is everything but shemale porn video good.
    blonde shemale nice hot shemale picture
    free shemale video jerking off Nice shemale tranny picture gallery cute.
    shemale in pantie hose amateur transsexual cute
    mature shemale nude shemale lesbian sex are nice.
    xxx trannies only shemale toons hard are nice.
    hot shemale photo sex free Is shemale tranny free or trannies cum xxx and post op transsexual xxx better than free shemale porn clip nice?
    free shemale sex cute shemale sex photo best
    beautiful post op transsexual free free shemale links nice is everything but shemale porn picture top.
    miriam transsexual top Is hentai shemale porn only or trannies having sex and rate trannies best better than shemale porn picture?
    shemale anime nice Hardcore transsexual pantie hose only is good.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  12. #12 |  tomass | 

    i’ve found this site ver interesting, cheer
    http://neroburningrom.wagoo2.com.

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  13. #13 |  mr xx | 

    Take your time to check out some relevant information dedicated to
    http://members.fortunecity.com/securitysystem

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  14. #14 |  Smit | 

    Hey, that shit is funny! Go Savage GO!
    http://nerobrningrom.tripod.com

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  15. #15 |  Smit | 

    Hey, that shit is funny! Go Savage GO!
    http://nerobrningrom.tripod.com

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  16. #16 |  xxxdiavolxxx | 

    I’m not sure if that adds to the discussion but I hope it helped in some way.
    http://pandantivirus.somee.com

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  17. #17 |  nikulinas | 

    I’m not sure if that adds to the discussion but I hope it helped in some way.
    http://norton2.jove.prohosting.com

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  18. #18 |  nikulinas | 

    software products lead the way with solutions to help you improve availability, performance, and automation.
    http://norton2.jove.prohosting.com

    Add karma Subtract karma  +0